Showing posts with label comment. Show all posts
Showing posts with label comment. Show all posts

Sunday, 4 March 2012

Steve Machin's comment on Channel 4's Great Ticketing Scandal

Steve Machin of Stormcrowd argues that whilst Channel 4’s Great Ticket Scandal raised some interesting points, it also missed out large chunks of the bigger picture…

Bringing an arsenal of investigative techniques to bear, Dispatches sought to expose what it had clearly predetermined was the dark side of the hitherto opaque and mysterious world of the concert industry - ticket sales and resales. The sense of entitlement and expectation that fans can show, rightly or wrongly, regarding an act and their tickets is startling and Dispatches exploited this highly-charged topic to create what it portrayed as a sensational scandal. But while the programme did uncover what appeared to be genuine legal concerns around some aspects of the descriptions of the resale market, I would argue that the sensationalist approach that it took overall failed to give an accurate representation of the complex economics of the 21st century ticketing market.

Rockonomics - In order to understand this, we first need a quick (and simplified) overview of rockonomics. Economists talk of supply and demand, yield management and mitigation of risk - do these principles apply to the sale of tickets? Absolutely. The promoter acts as an initial speculator, buying the performances (and related services such as venue hire) hoping that they can make a profit on the total cost of the gig or tour, by selling sufficient tickets at the right prices. The promoter assumes risk from the performers.

The perceived demand impacts upon supply variables - ticket pricing, the number of tickets made available, and the size of the venues. The better the tour can predict demand, and price tickets accurately against fans expectation of value, the more effective the yield will be in returning a profit on the risked capital.

What risk? A question asked by the programme was “how hard is it to predict how successful a comeback tour by Take That might be?” It was raised precisely to undermine the notion that there is any risk in promoting concerts. While some tours are inherently more risky than others, one only has to look at the annual returns filed by Live Nation to see razor thin margins where even a small amount of increased risk could significantly impact upon the business.

Risky Business

So how do the promoters reduce their risk? By selling tickets at prices that are low enough to ensure that sufficient attendees provide a return on investment, and that price, for some of the tickets is below market value, while for others is above market value.

It is a common complaint that “music or concerts cannot be reduced to a commodity and traded” - I am no apologist for the areas of the resale market that were exposed as legally challenging from a consumer protection viewpoint, nor do I make any claims as to whether it is right or wrong to trade tickets - that is not the subject of this piece – but what is clear is that tickets ARE traded like commodities. That is in part because there continues to be a consistent disparity between the market price of a ticket and the published face value at which it is first sold. Not all tickets are created equal, and over time the value of each ticket will vary - see a recent article by PRS for Music for a good review of the economics of ticket discounting - the “front rows” get traded while there are still seats available "at the back"

The internet has simply made it much easier to buy and sell most products, everything from iPods to insurance and all points in between. Tickets are no different and with arbitrage opportunity available the internet allows buyers and sellers to easily connect and transact at market price - leading to the creation of an additional layer of speculation - fans who buy more than they need, and professional brokers investing in buying tickets purely to resell - the cold harvesting of tickets.

The whole truth

The Dispatches investigation wanted to ensure that this programme was car-crash television of the highest order. In doing so they did not tell the whole story about many of the points that they covered.

1 - Fans learned that a significant proportion of tickets sold on ViaGoGo and Seatwave are not sourced from individual fans looking to sell tickets that can no longer be used - the notion of being exclusively fan-to-fan is a misnomer as many tickets come from brokers and box-offices. It is worth noting, as Dispatches failed to mention, that Seatwave states clearly on its website when tickets have been made available directly by the box office.

2 - We also heard that on some tours, ViaGoGo and Seatwave are provided tickets directly by the promoter to sell at the best price possible. The presumption was that tickets are always sold at astronomical prices above face-value. In reality, tickets are often sold on exchanges, or other discount channel sites at significantly below face value. The cold truth is that exchanges can provide access to a cohort of demonstrably price insensitive customers who are willing to pay a premium to acquire tickets closer to the event date.

3 - More surprising was the evidence that staff at ViaGoGo has purchased tickets from primary vendors such as Ticketmaster to resell using the company’s own “internal seller” accounts. There is a significant difference between market clearing price (which is generally considered a good thing economically) and an exchange making the market under false pretenses.

The public rage on twitter during the broadcast was aimed squarely at the exchanges and promoters, and assumed (as Dispatches suggested) that artists or their management are not aware that tickets are allocated to exchanges. Speaking to Pollstar reporter John Gammon following the broadcast, Live Nation’s Paul Latham stated that Live Nation has never allocated tickets without the knowledge and consent of the artists’ management. The Concert Promoters Association issued a statement to the effect that placing tickets into the secondary market reduces prices by increasing supply, and ensures that additional value is captured within the industry.

Dispatches also failed to mention that there are already mechanisms available that make ticket reselling more difficult should a tour choose to. These include paperless tickets that require the purchasing credit card to be present or photo-ticket schemes such as that used by Glastonbury festival. Removing speculators however exposes the tour to true demand, a point made eloquently earlier this week by Bob Lefsetz in his industry blog (www.lefsetz.com/) and this is not always good news for the artists or promoters.

The fans pay the bills

The wider impact of price sensitivity on the concert business must be considered for everyone competing for the same share of the fan wallet. Do fans who decide to not spend money on a ticket spend it on other concerts or other music entertainment products, or do they spend it on computer games or fashion or some other category? Do fans who spend high sums of money on concert tickets spend less at the venue on F&B or on merchandise? Will dynamic pricing be a reality and provide genuine real-time market pricing for concerts and would that be embraced by the industry and fans alike as a fair solution?

Ultimately in such a complex market there are a lot more questions than answers - while emotions clearly run high when discussing entertainment tickets, does it mean the government should legislate and introduce price regulation into efficient markets? After all, the face value is an arbitrary price that could have been set much higher or much lower. And anyhow, now that these markets exist, can the genie be put back in the bottle? Would it be helpful, and to whom? Dispatches successfully demonstrated that some fans care a lot about ticket pricing but that even more care about transparency.

Built in part on largely one-sided questioning designed to elicit highly emotional responses from disgruntled fans who chose to purchase tickets (and similarly grief stricken tales from disappointed fans who chose not to) the programme failed to make a balanced representation of issues affecting the ticket business. All the primary stakeholders in the concert industry that I speak to are concerned with how to get more fans, to habitually attend more shows, more often. That is the wider challenge that frames this debate.

--

Steve Machin (@stevemachin) runs Stormcrowd (@stormcrowd) - an entertainment consultancy specializing in ticketing and social commerce - www.stormcrowd.com/

Further reading:

Bob Lefsetz (@lefsetz) on ticket scalping

Pollstar review of Dispatches

PRS article on ticket discounting

PRS article on Secondary Market Analysis

Thursday, 5 February 2009

Comment piece from RotD Magazine 05/02

Reproduced from Record of the Day's Weekly Magazine. To Subscribe, go to recordoftheday.com

As Twitter jumps over to the mainstream in the UK, how can the music industry make sure it’s getting the most out of it? James Foley reports:

It has been a watershed couple of weeks for Twitter in the UK. Whether it be Stephen Fry and Jonathan Ross discussing it on TV, numerous Radio 1 DJs using it live on-air, or just the sheer volume of your business contacts who try and cajole all of us into using it (today's Daily Mirror even had a 'What Is Twitter?' piece on p3), it would appear you're best off just surrendering to its current surge in usage.

If you're not quite sure what it is, then you are probably very reticent to engage in yet another social networking tool. Difficult as explaining it in one sentence might be, let's have a shot: Twitter is a mixture of short status updates to a network of people you're signed up to following.

Traffic on Twitter has grown by a staggering 974 % in the last year, so if you're not already using it for your music business needs, the window of opportunity to join while it's getting hotter is open now. As your daily social networking tasks (update Facebook groups/ check MySpace/ upload to Flickr etc) threaten to overshadow your actual proper work tasks, you might understandably approach yet another network with some cynicism or trepidation, but fear not - the beauty of Twitter is its simplicity.

As we started using Twitter regularly for RotD business last October at In The City, we were instantly attracted to it as a tool of letting other industry folk where we were, which gig we were at, any breaking news and whatever good quotes from panels we could express in 140 characters. It's no surprise to learn then that Twitter's initial explosion in the US happened just before another conference, SXSW 2007 where hordes of tech-savvy visitors to SXSW Interactive used it to swap details of where they were and answering Twitter's founding question: 'What are you doing?'.

As the crowd has shifted from tech-pioneers to mass-market take-up, it would be a shame if industry missed the boat on Twitter. Given how slow the industry has been to utilize the full extent of Facebook as a music service in its five years of existence, Twitter's short, quick, yet personal style of communication cries out to be taken advantage of – in a smart way – by the music industry. The seeds have already been sown by many of the professionals, labels, musicians and media outlets we've seen flock to Twitter in recent times. Some use it successfully, while others are clearly not 'getting it'. So, what are the potential best uses?

Patrick Clifton, in charge of social networking strategy for Darling Social Services, told us that Twitter has the potential to be the first point of communication with an audience or potential market. "Imagine a hotly-anticipated tour being made available exclusively by posting a link first on Twitter then everywhere else, for example."

Artists are using Twitter to open a channel of conversation with their followers, but one which they can control. Lily Allen, for example can tell her fans her fears of appearing on GMTV, Calvin Harris can bitch about his label as he makes his difficult second album and Tinchy Stryder can let us know about his housing situation.. But it's not all trivial updates: we've found artists that interact with fans directly promote an interest in their music. Imogen Heap is one such artist who uses it well, documenting her recording process but also linking to her fresh content elsewhere on the web. Coldplay don't use it themselves (yet), but a web-savvy employee of theirs posts Tweets as he follows their radio sessions and breaks competitions and web exclusives. And, in a sign that the service is crossing over to an increasingly mainstream audience, Jimmy Eat World have launched a tour site which combines concert-specific Tweets into a chat-stream.

Ritch Ames from Online PR and digital PR firm Tomorrow Never Knows advised us that the key approach for music industry users of Twitter is to keep it personal, "Simply spamming the service every now and again will actually see the amount of followers you receive fall - unlike many other social networks, people will decide to break up your friendship…Twitter is based on a quick, precise and to-the-point messages, and they have to come from the person themselves, not a PR and not an office intern."

The labels we currently enjoy on Twitter have the potential to take followers, not just as potential customers to new releases, but also as investors in their brand and ethos. Simply blasting out a stream of feeds to your followers won't gain you an audience, particularly not as that audience explodes and people become more selective about who they follow.

Likewise for media outlets, simply hooking up an RSS feed to Twitter to let them know about new articles won't curry any favour, but engaging with your followers will. One of our favourite online music publications, Popjustice, is also one of our favourites to catch on Twitter, simply because Peter Robinson's updates share the personality and humour of the website – it allows the reader to consume more of what they like, with little extra effort on the publisher's behalf.

To those who had dismissed Twitter as a passing fad, or to those who haven't quite got their heads around it, we urge you not to doubt its potential power and to get on there and give it a shot. We'd add the caveat that, as with any social-networking site, it is not the be-all and end-all of any business strategy. But you should be there as Twitter grows - not just through its main site, but also as an eco-system of applications and sites growing around it will too.

Related Reading:

Follow @Recordoftheday of course.

While you’re there, check out editor Nicola Slade’s (@mislaid) – particularly for the 9am ‘top story’ update.

@drownedinsound have set up MusicTwitters, a feed of musicians and music sites, blogs and labels who use Twitter.

Heather Macdonald has compiled some tips for the best use of Twitter for industry people.

Gerd Leonhard gives seven reasons why everyone in the music industry should try Twitter.

And might endear yourself to your Twitter community by donating your artist's music to Twestival